House Prosecution: VP Sara's Sworn GenCorp Shares Admission Could Carry More Weight


 House Prosecution: VP Sara's Sworn Admission of GenCorp Shares Could Carry More Weight

MANILA – Vice President Sara Duterte's sworn declaration that she was a shareholder of GenCorp Industries Inc. could carry greater evidentiary weight than corporate records denying her ownership, the House prosecution argued Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026, during her impeachment trial.

Private prosecutor Lorna Kapunan stressed that Duterte personally declared her GenCorp shareholding in her 2024 and 2025 Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALNs), making it an admission that could be used as evidence against her.

The issue arose after GenCorp in-house counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay insisted that Duterte was not listed as a shareholder in the company's general information sheets (GIS) filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

Asked why Duterte would declare shares she supposedly did not own, Punay replied, "I cannot answer for the vice president, ma'am." Asked whether Duterte herself could explain the discrepancy, Punay said, "She can answer, yes."

Senator-Judge Panfilo "Ping" Lacson challenged Punay for giving greater evidentiary weight to GenCorp's SEC records than to Duterte's sworn SALN.

"The SEC records, Your Honor," Punay replied when asked which document carried more weight.

"SEC records? Are you sure?" Lacson pressed.

"For me, the SEC records, Your Honor," she maintained.

Lacson cited Section 27, Rule 130 of the Rules of Court, which allows a party's declarations to be presented as evidence against that party.

"Mas may probative weight or admissibility weight 'yung admission against interest (An admission against interest carries more probative weight or admissibility weight)," Lacson said, emphasizing that Duterte's SALN was notarized.

Kapunan supported Lacson's position, arguing that Duterte's sworn declaration should carry greater weight than a GIS certified by a corporate secretary.

"Forgetting, Your Honor, that the SALN itself is a public document," Kapunan said.

She stressed that Duterte personally signed and swore to the SALN, unlike the corporate filing certified by another person.

Senate Presiding Officer Francis "Chiz" Escudero acknowledged that an admission has been described as the "queen of evidence," but said each senator-judge must ultimately determine the weight of the competing documents.

Escudero also questioned why Duterte declared an interest in GenCorp itself rather than specifying that her investment was limited to one Jollibee branch.

"Hindi po niya in-specify na 'yung Jollibee lang sa (She did not specify that her investment is only the Jollibee store at) Times Square," he said.

Punay maintained that Duterte's declaration alone did not establish ownership.

"Her unilateral declaration, Your Honor, will not make her a stockholder," she said.

Kapunan argued that if Duterte's admission was accurate, her financial interest would extend to GenCorp's five Jollibee franchises in Davao City: Bolton, Matina Crossing, GMall, Times Square and Abreeza.

The dispute also raises questions under Article VII, Section 13 of the Constitution, which prohibits the vice president from participating in any business during his or her tenure and from holding direct or indirect financial interests in government contracts, franchises or special privileges granted by the government.

Earlier, Punay confirmed that Duterte received PHP2.14 million from GenCorp between 2022 and 2025, describing the payments as returns of capital from a "loose investment."

The controversy forms part of Article II, the remaining impeachment charge involving at least PHP817.87 million in alleged unexplained wealth.

QUICK SUMMARY

What: House prosecution argues VP Sara Duterte's sworn SALN declaration of GenCorp shares could carry greater evidentiary weight than corporate records denying her ownership

Where: Manila

When: Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026

Impact on the Philippines: The issue forms part of Article II, the remaining impeachment charge involving at least PHP817.87 million in alleged unexplained wealth

Source: Philippine News Agency (PNA)

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post