Escudero Raises Possible Overdeclaration in VP Sara's SALN
Senate Presiding Officer Francis "Chiz" Escudero raised the possibility of overdeclaration in Vice President Sara Duterte's Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN) on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, after the Senate impeachment court found a ₱587,151 difference between the declared acquisition cost of a Samal Island property and the purchase price reflected in its deed of sale.
During the second day of the defense's presentation, Escudero examined whether the ₱4,041,000 acquisition cost declared in Duterte's SALN, compared with the ₱3,453,849 purchase price in a 2018 deed of absolute sale, could be explained by additional expenses rather than an undeclared asset. "But if I want to be safe, isn't it better to over-declare what I paid instead of under-declaring it?" Escudero asked. He also sought clarification on whether declaring a higher acquisition cost than the amount stated in a deed of sale would constitute a violation of SALN disclosure rules.
The discussion centered on a disputed property in the Kembali Coast development in the Island Garden City of Samal, which the defense maintains was already included in Duterte's asset declarations. Defense counsel Lindon Bacquel maintained that the higher amount could be attributed to additional expenses incurred in acquiring the property. "But our position remains that these are the same property which are declared in the Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth," Bacquel said. The defense argued that acquisition costs may include transfer taxes, documentary stamp taxes, registration fees, and other transaction-related expenses.
Escudero, however, noted that ordinary transfer expenses might not fully account for the difference between the two figures. "I computed it, Atty. Lindon. It's still more than that. You're talking roughly, capital gains tax, transfer taxes, doc stamps. It won't reach 12 percent of total," he said. The presiding officer also raised the possibility that the amount declared in the SALN reflected what was actually paid for the property, although the defense declined to speculate on that explanation.
Private prosecutor Benjamin Tolosa Jr. rejected the suggestion that the difference resulted from overdeclaration, insisting that the land title and SALN entry referred to separate properties. "First and foremost, Your Honor, our position is these are not the same property," Tolosa said. He argued that under Civil Service Commission Memorandum Circular No. 2, series of 2013, acquisition cost should reflect the amount paid to acquire the property, excluding taxes and fees associated with transferring ownership.
The prosecution maintained that discrepancies in acquisition dates, property descriptions, and declared values supported its position that the SALN entry referred to a different property.
Source: Philippine News Agency (Wilnard Bacelonia). Photo: Screengrab from Senate livestream
